If you’ve ever typed an -ing word into the NYT Spelling Bee and been surprised by the result — either a satisfying “Nice!” or a baffling rejection — you’re not alone. The puzzle’s word list makes some subtle grammatical choices that trip up even seasoned players. At the heart of a lot of this confusion is a classic grammar question: is that -ing word a gerund (acting as a noun) or a present participle (acting as a verb or adjective)? Understanding the difference isn’t just a fun linguistics detour — it can actually change your scoring strategy and help you predict which words the Bee will accept. Let’s dig in.
The Basic Grammar: Gerunds vs. Present Participles
Both gerunds and present participles are formed by adding -ing to a verb’s base form, which is exactly why they cause so much confusion. The difference lies entirely in how they function within a sentence — and that distinction matters deeply to morphology, the study of word structure and word forms.
A gerund is an -ing word that functions as a noun. Think of it this way: if you can substitute the word with “it” or replace it with a standard noun and the sentence still makes sense, you’ve got a gerund.
- Running is my favorite hobby. (Running = the activity, a noun)
- Baking takes patience. (Baking = the craft, a noun)
- She loves reading. (Reading = the activity, a noun)
A present participle, on the other hand, functions as part of a verb phrase or as an adjective modifying a noun. It doesn’t stand alone as a thing — it describes an action in progress or modifies something else.
- She is running down the street. (Running = part of the verb “is running”)
- The baking bread smells amazing. (Baking = adjective modifying bread)
- He was reading quietly. (Reading = part of the verb phrase)
Same spelling. Completely different grammatical roles. This is what makes -ing words such fascinating — and occasionally maddening — territory in both grammar and word games.
How the Spelling Bee Handles -ING Words
The NYT Spelling Bee uses a curated word list that reflects standard dictionary entries. Here’s the key insight for players: the Bee generally accepts words that exist as independent dictionary entries. Many gerunds have earned their own standalone dictionary definitions because they’ve drifted into truly noun-like status over time — they describe a concept, a practice, or an activity in a way that’s become permanently fixed in the language.
For example, baking, running, and fishing are all well-established nouns in most major dictionaries. They appear as headwords with noun definitions. These are the kinds of -ing words you’re more likely to see validated by the Bee.
Present participles, by contrast, are typically not listed as separate dictionary entries — they’re understood as the verb form of the base word, generated predictably by adding -ing. Because the Bee’s word list tends to avoid what lexicographers call “inflected forms” (regular, predictable verb conjugations), a present participle that hasn’t developed an independent noun meaning is less likely to make the cut.
This is where verb-forms knowledge becomes genuinely useful for Bee strategy. When you’re staring at a potential -ing word, ask yourself: does this word have a life beyond its verb form? Has it become a thing in its own right?
Why Some -ING Words Get Accepted and Others Don’t
The Bee’s editorial decisions around -ing words reflect something linguists have studied for years: lexicalization. This is the process by which a grammatical form gradually becomes a fixed vocabulary item with its own meaning. When a present participle gets used as a noun so consistently that people stop thinking of it as a verb form, it becomes lexicalized — and that’s when it earns a dictionary entry as a gerund or noun.
Consider the word hiking. It started as a present participle (“She is hiking the trail”), but it’s now so firmly established as a noun (“Hiking is her passion,” “a hiking trail,” “hiking gear”) that most dictionaries list it independently. The Bee is likely to accept it. Meanwhile, a word like mumbling — while perfectly valid English — may not have that same independent noun status and might be excluded as a mere verb inflection.
This distinction in morphology explains a lot of the Bee’s seemingly inconsistent behavior. It’s not random — it’s rooted in how dictionaries document the evolution of words.
Practical Tips for Spelling Bee Players
Once you understand the gerund vs. present participle dynamic, you can start making smarter guesses. Here are some strategies to keep in mind:
- Think noun first. Before you type any -ing word, ask yourself if it functions as a standalone noun. “I love swimming” (noun) is more dictionary-worthy than “She is swimming” (verb phrase).
- Look for compound-friendly words. Gerunds that pair easily with other nouns — like fishing rod, running shoes, or hiking boots — tend to be firmly lexicalized and dictionary-listed, making them stronger Bee candidates.
- Be cautious with obscure base verbs. If the base verb itself is unusual or rare, its -ing form is less likely to have developed into a recognized noun. The Bee tends to favor -ing words with broad, well-documented usage.
- Trust common, activity-based words. Words that describe hobbies, crafts, sports, or regular human activities — baking, painting, singing, surfing — have almost certainly earned noun status and are worth trying.
- Don’t avoid all participles. Some present participles have so thoroughly crossed over into adjective or noun territory that they appear in dictionaries anyway. When in doubt, give it a shot — the Bee won’t penalize you for a wrong guess.
The Bigger Picture: Why Grammar Knowledge Improves Your Game
It might seem like a stretch to say that understanding grammar makes you better at a spelling puzzle, but the connection is real. The Bee is ultimately a vocabulary game, and vocabulary is built on morphology — how words are structured, how they evolve, and how they’re classified. Players who understand verb-forms, root words, prefixes, and suffixes consistently outperform those who rely purely on memorization.
When you internalize the difference between a gerund and a present participle, you’re not just learning a grammar rule — you’re learning to read the logic behind the Bee’s word list. You start to understand why certain words feel like they “should” be there and others don’t. That intuition, sharpened by grammatical awareness, is one of the best tools a Bee player can develop.
Plus, there’s something genuinely satisfying about cracking a puzzle with knowledge rather than luck. Finding that obscure gerund because you recognized it as a lexicalized noun — not just a verb with -ing tacked on — is a small but real intellectual victory.
Wrapping Up
The gerund vs. present participle distinction is one of those grammar concepts that seems purely academic until you’re staring at a Spelling Bee grid wondering whether that word counts. Now you know: the Bee tends to favor -ing words that have established themselves as genuine nouns in the dictionary, rooted in the morphology of lexicalization. Keep asking whether your -ing word is a thing or just a doing, and you’ll find yourself making smarter, more confident guesses. Happy buzzing!